Abstracts
Walther, Andreas (ed.) 1996: Junge Erwachsene in Europa - jenseits der
Normalbiographie? (Young Adults in Europe - beyond "normal biography"?).
Leske+Budrich: Opladen.
Andreas Walther's introduction starts from the empirical evidence
that there is an increasing share of young people up to 35 years (or even
more) participating in institutional measures and programmes conceptualized
as youth programmes (up to 25 years of age). The history of the last decades
of German and European youth research and youth policies shows that the
age limits of youth have been postponed more and more and that this postponement
increasingly has been subject of scientific debates. Behind these strategies
of extension of youth structural changes and problems of social integration
affecting the European societies do appear: integration into the labour
market gets more and more difficult and insecure, periods of education
and training are prolonged, gender relations are irritated by the coincidence
of a dissolution and restructuration of former inequality and life styles
stand for coping strategies between security and experimental life forms.
Obviously previous youth research was stuck to the so-called "normal life
course" presupposing the individual solution of these tasks in the youth
stage. In order not to hide the ongoing changes and challenges of social
integration and social exclusion behind the construction of a new social
group "Young Adults", the author suggests to use the concept first of all
as an analytical concept to open new perspectives on growing up and social
integration.
Lynne Chisholm takes up the basic question concerning the relation
between the phenomenon "Young Adults" and its social reality. Does the
concept "Young Adults" refer to the extension of the life course by a new
life stage as a response to the increased complexity of planning one's
life? Do "Young Adults" stand for a fundamental change in social integration
and adulthood itself? In order to prove the plausibility of the second
hypothesis Chisholm asks why so little attention is paid to the adult life
stage by both research and policy. The contingency of individual
biographies is confronted with the linear structure of institutionalized
life courses. Thus, social integration in general and the life stage of
adulthood in particular are affected. "Young Adults" are considered to
be "sociologically more female" as the competence to cope with contingent
life perspectives is developed rather in female than in male transitions
into the adult society.
Sven Morch considers "Young Adults" to be a conceptual instrument
by which social reality is constructed. In this course, he analyses young
adults in the sense of a grown historical phenomenon, which began to develop
end of the 18th century. Since end of the Second World War a popularization
and widening of "youth time" has taken place. Nowadays individuals ,become
very early young, very late adult, however". On the one hand everybody
has access to youth, which means that everybody is given the same starting
conditions mainly with regard to education. Modern youth is acting as a
decisive individual and social transformator. On the other hand, young
adults increasingly are under pressure, since only they are made responsible
for the results of their life arrangements. A crucial problem is the so-called
Container youth": This is the group of young adults excluded from the educational
society through a system of special projects "containers" which
keep them apart from the labour market and from social integration. In
the future, the concept "Young Adults" should be analysed with regard to
social change on the one hand, but also as transformation period between
childhood and adulthood on the other hand.
José Machado Pais points to the increased reversibility
of transitions from youth to adulthood. This consideration is based on
empirical data on juvenile life conditions and generational relations raised
in Portugal. The reversibility of becoming adult mainly caused by
the difficulties of entering and staying in the labour market creates
new values and life forms invading the centre of society from its margins.
Using Turner's concept of dramaturgy of rites this process produces rites
of conversion as well as diversion, social inventions as well as social
exclusion. An important support of young people in this situation is the
"welfare family" providing them with social and financial capital. The
reversibility of transitions and the coincidence of rites of separation
without passage (to complete adulthood) with rites of passage without separation
lead to the picture of the "yo-yo-generation".
Els Peters and Manuela du Bois-Reymond develop the same
model of "yo-yo-trajectories" from a Dutch perspective based on empirical
data putting the focus on changed gender relations. The process of social
modernization and its effects of individualization lead to contradictions
between the life perspectives of different generations of women (mothers
and daughters) as well as between the life perspectives of young women
and young men. Strategies of transitions are structured by the dichotomies
risks/opportunities and choice/pressure which mainly depend on gender and
education. This "yo-yo-model" is applied to the orientations of young women
with regard to their perceptions and strategies with regard to the combination
of work and family. The authors consider young women to be advantaged in
gaining a reflexive biographical position in comparison to young men as
they have to cope with restricted opportunities on the one side and receive
encouraging support from their mothers on the other side.
Olivier Galland directs his attention to the observation that
the relation between young adults and society is one of mutual exclusion
and disapproval. However, empirical data concerning the situation of education
and the labour-market especially in France lead Galland to a profound modification
of this assertion. Thus, due to an extended and widely used period of education,
only a small part of young adults is concerned by unemployment. Moreover,
the majority of educated young adults have good opportunities in the job
market. With regard to the attitude of youth towards their society, Galland
points out that young Europeans feel more integrated and content today
than ten years ago. It is only a minority of young adults for whom both
their attitude and their employment situation have deteriorated at a high
degree. Galland draws the conclusion that society neither is marginalizing
young adults nor is being refused by them. Nevertheless, social polarization
has increased: Whereas the majority of young adults have good opportunities
of improving its/their situation, a minority is more and more confronted
with social disintegration.
Hans-Ulrich Müller describes "Young Adults" in the context
of the process of modern individualization as a new life stage which cannot
be interpreted as prolonged youth" in the traditional sense. This life
stage is characterized by discontinuities, since it implies diverse, disparate
experiments of coping with life and realization of interests. This process
of trial and error leads to fragile, risky identities mainly where young
adults in big cities are concerned. However, social institutions do not
have adequate instruments by which they can support young adults in coping
with life and actualizing their interests. That is why young adults find
themselves in a structural socio-political vacuum". Therefore, they have
to rely on informal networks of support and on the family of origin. Moreover,
they are dependent on communication and co-operation milieux. This situation
requires the development of policies as part of local social policy being
orientated especially to the demands of young adults. These policies should
refer to the general conditions of life and scopes of action. Moreover,
they should take up and include the historically new constitutive elements
of young adulthood.
Andreas Schröer describes the specific life stage of young
adults living in Eastern Germany with regard to the social process of transformation.
Young adults encounter the demands of individualized life courses with
a modern form of collectivity. Social networks are functional inasmuch
as they replace missing or inadequate institutional support. They offer
temporal and material security. Moreover, they constitute a normative frame
that provides role models for the construction of identities. Therefore,
the social networks are not only "emergency organizations" but also relevant
elements for the development of life styles. These life styles are characterized
by a high degree of reproductive activities, which are indispensable for
the stabilization and expansion of collective everyday life.
Enzo Morgagni and Luigi Guerra describe the specific forms that
the general structural changes of transition take in Italy, especially
in the region Emilia-Romagna. Referring to empirical data on increasing
overlaps of education, training and work within individual life cycles
and on the "long family" caring for young people until they set up an own
family they show the evident plausibility of the concept. Regarding the
prolongation of transitions and the overlap of different life phases it
is important to consider differences according to social class or gender.
The empirical evidence is confirmed by youth and educational facilities
which are confronted by a change of their target group by age and quality
of demands. However, the authors suggest that young adults in Emilia Romagna
should be characterized as a "silent group". Due to the "long family" functioning
as a resource network young adults don't appear as a visible (or audible)
group in public, they don't create specific life forms, nor do they participate
in youth rebellions. This contradiction between invisibility and social
demands is reproduced within the institutions concerned: Though taking
notice of the changing age structure they don't adapt the perceptive concepts
of their target group with regard to the categories "youth" and "adulthood".
The social risk of a large non-future-oriented group might only be prevented
by "collaborating" with these new phenomena.
Andreu Lopez Blasco as well focusses the intra-familiar relationships
of young adults. In the Spanish region Communidad Valenciana young people
up to 30 years play a more important demographic role than in any other
European region whereas the unemployment rate is one of the highest in
Europe. Therefore the most striking finding of a recent empirical research
has been the positive attitude of young women and men towards both family
and society. These orientations are the presupposition for families to
sustain insecure transitions and to make them continue for a longer and
longer time. In consideration of the short spanish process of democratization
it is the parents' generation to be sceptical about the real harmony of
family relationships.
Barbara Stauber and Andreas Walther try to answer the
question whether the contributions collected in this book represent a European
discourse on "Young Adults". What are the conditions and perspectives of
such an intercultural process? The irritations of coinciding similarities
and differences comparing the phenomenon "Young Adults" in the European
context are considered to be the result of one-dimensional schedules of
comparison between "traditional" and "modern" societies. For an analytical
separation of presumed common structures and different phenomena a concept
of different "paths of modernization" might be useful. The methodological
suggestion made is not to keep stuck on "mere" comparison but to initiate
common processes of defining and interpreting changes in social structure
for which local, regional and national perspectives reveal themselves to
be too limited. Such an interpretative process may be described as a pendularious
movement between the own (local or regional) and another cultural (or European)
perspective. This movement understood as "intercultural hermeneutics"
is the intercultural extension of the hermeneutic cycle and might
therefore give also new impulses for ethnomethodological approaches on
the local and regional level.
|